The concept of opinion is multifaceted, playing a significant role in both practical and political domains. While it is often viewed as inferior to scientific knowledge due to its subjective nature, opinion can be a valuable starting point for understanding truth. In many cases, opinions are formed through immediate perceptions, hearsay, or the interpretation of signs, which can be misleading. However, the aggregation of diverse opinions can lead to a more accurate judgment, particularly in democratic regimes where public opinion is crucial.
In the realm of politics, the collective opinion of the populace can guide decision-making and reflect the will of the people. The ancient Greeks considered opinion to be the lowest form of knowledge because of its uncertain relationship with truth. Nonetheless, opinion can be a precursor to truth, as it often represents an initial interpretation of the world. For instance, Copernicus's opinion that the Earth orbits the Sun was later validated by Galileo's observations, demonstrating that opinions can sometimes be correct.
The truth value of an opinion is relative and depends on various factors, including the sincerity and conscientiousness with which it is expressed. While science seeks to establish objective truths through rigorous methods, opinion is inherently subjective and personal. However, this does not render opinion useless; rather, it highlights the importance of considering multiple viewpoints to arrive at a more informed understanding.
Ultimately, opinion is not inherently wrong, and its value lies in its ability to provide initial insights and foster discussion. By acknowledging the limitations and potential of opinion, we can harness its power to inform and shape our understanding of the world.
Extract
[...] For the ancient Greeks, opinion is the lowest degree of knowledge since its problem is its relationship with truth. We can have an opinion without knowing, there is no passage to reflection. For them, the search for truth is fundamental. For example, in The Republic, Plato denigrates opinion by showing the benefits for the man who has come out of the cave (by force), and has not followed the opinion of his imprisoned companions. Here, the chained men are ignorant, and are not aware of it. [...]
[...] An opinion is true because it is the expression of a genuine and sincere sentiment. The truth of an opinion is particular in that it is expressed in good faith, sincerely, and conscientiously. For example, if my opinion is that the sky is gray, it is because I am colorblind, thus constituting a truth about me. To state one's opinion is to express a truth about the one who states it. In conclusion, in the face of science that proceeds through rigorous methods, opinion is wrong, because this is more of the sensible world that is easily deceived. [...]
[...] Linked related to the subject that it expresses, it informs and emits a truth about the one who formulates it. Finally, an opinion can also be right when it is the result of an enlightened debate, which certainly does not lead to knowledge but goes beyond prejudice. It should be noted that an opinion cannot justify itself. The proof is always external, for example a scientific reasoning. [...]
[...] When opinion is true, it affirms it without knowing it or without knowing that it is true. In addition, it does not allow itself to be questioned: trying to analyze or demonstrate it is to leave the framework of opinion and go into reflection. Imposes itself and it remains an opinion in as much as it is incontestable, it is not contested. Knowing whether an opinion is true or not only makes sense if one is omniscient, which is impossible. [...]
[...] Thus, it is conceivable that the opinion is right as soon as the truth is defined in a broader and less strict sense. III_There is another form of truth, particularly in practical and political domains, in which the opinion is right The opinion can be right in practical situations In relation to the field of knowledge, opinion has no real value. However, it makes it possible to consider the probability of being true but without real certainty. Nevertheless, opinion can prove to be useful. [...]
