Evolution of the President's Role: A Comparative Analysis of the 1875 Laws and 1946 Constitution.
Download
Read an extract
Themes
French President, Republic, constitutional laws, executive power, legislative power, parliamentary regime, assembly regime, Third Republic, Fourth Republic
Reader
Abstract
Extract
of 2
Abstract
Unlock the evolution of France's presidential power: Explore how the constitutional laws of 1875 and the 1946 constitution reshaped the President's role within the executive. Discover the surprising commonalities and differences between these two pivotal documents, shaping the country's leadership. Dive into the historical context and expert analysis to understand the impact on France's governance. Learn more about the transformation of the President's status and prerogatives over time.
Extract
[...] In what ways have the laws of 1875 and the Constitution of 1946 increased or decreased the status and prerogatives of the President of the Republic within the executive? - Introduction The political scientist Richard Rose, in an article entitled 'Presidents and Prime Ministers: Elements of Comparison', published in the journal Powers in May 1987, wrote : « [?] no matter what name one gives it, there always exists a position that holds a primary place within any system. France is included as an example in the article, taking into account the political particularity surrounding the figure that governs it, the President of the Republic. [...]
[...] The President of the Republic has the particularity of having been defined from a disparate set of laws and then by a single text. The difference in political regimes and the distinct spirit of the legal texts have not prevented common points from existing around the status and powers of the President of the Republic between the laws of 1875 and the constitution of 1946 But taking into account the temporal distance between the latter, it is evident that notable differences have appeared, having consequences on the prerogatives of the one who will be commonly considered as the head of state (II). [...]
[...] His role and powers are now defined in articles 5 to 19 of the Constitution of 1958, and his legal status in articles 67 and 68. They were, however, once established by the law of 25 February 1875, one of the three constitutional laws of 1875 that enabled the institutions of the Third Republic (1870-1940) to be ratified until the outbreak of World War II and the establishment of the Vichy regime (1940-1944). From the end of the war, the Fourth Republic is established and is equipped with a constitution on October giving priority to the legislative power with an executive power framed, a compromise between the defenders of an assembly regime and the supporters of a parliamentary regime. [...]
