Criminal liability, medical negligence, involuntary homicide, fault, causal link, damage, hospital responsibility, legal person, natural person, Penal Code, Article 121-2, Criminal Code
Analysis of the conditions required for criminal liability in cases of involuntary homicide committed by medical professionals, focusing on the fault, causal link, and damage.
[...] In addition, the complementary penalties are: definitive or up to 5 years' prohibition of exercising the professional / social activity linked to the offense, prohibition of holding a weapon, suspension / annulment of the driving license, a drug awareness course or the dissemination of the conviction. In this case, Dr. Knock committed a characterized fault. He faces up to 3 years' imprisonment and ?45,000 as the main penalty. II) The criminal liability of Mr. Lacroix, hospital director In this case, Mr. [...]
[...] III) The criminal liability of Mrs. Mayor, the mayor of the commune In this case, the circulation of the damage-causing vehicles, one of which was responsible for an accident causing paraplegia, was based on a municipal decree of the commune whose mayor is Mrs. Mayor. The fact that a mayor issued a vague decree allowing the use of damage-causing vehicles on public ski slopes, which caused an accident, can it engage her criminal liability? Legally, the mayor who contributed to creating the situation that led to an involuntary attack on physical integrity may see her criminal liability engaged. [...]
[...] In this case, the monitors are experienced, they perform this dive daily with dozens of tourists without a hitch and the moray is usually calm and does not regularly frequent the corner where the dive took place. Thus, the moray attack was unpredictable, the monitors did not commit a fault and therefore cannot see their criminal liability engaged. II) The criminal liability of the manager of the company, Mr. Rangiroa In this case, Mrs. Claire, a victim of a moray bite that occurred during a diving session of the company managed by Mr. Rangiroa, seeks compensation. [...]
[...] Who are the penal responsible for Mr. Bump's accident? Therefore, we must consider the penal responsibility of Mr. Bump, the driver of the machine Mr. Marshal, the security deputy and that of Madame Mayor (III). The penal responsibility of Mr. Bump, the driver of the machine In this case, a skier is hit by a damage vehicle driven by a municipal employee on the order of the security deputy and this accident causes the paraplegia of the victim who seeks to be compensated. [...]
[...] As a result, the offense is materially constituted, and the legal person, namely the hospital, can engage its criminal liability for the patient's death. Repression of involuntary homicide by the hospital In law, the legal person who commits an involuntary homicide faces a main penalty of ?225,000 in fine (Articles 131-38 and 221-7 of the Penal Code). The complementary penalties can be the prohibition of exercising the professional activity related to the offense, judicial supervision of the legal person, or the posting and dissemination of its sentence. [...]
APA Style reference
For your bibliographyOnline reading
with our online readerContent validated
by our reading committee