Understanding Agnotology: The Study of Ignorance and Its Impact on Scientific Knowledge and Gender Biases
Download
Read an extract
Themes
Agnotology, ignorance, science, feminism, gender stereotypes, Londa Schiebinger, Matilda effect, Alice Ball, Marie Curie, scientific knowledge
Reader
Abstract
Extract
of 3
Abstract
Explore the groundbreaking field of agnotology, the study of ignorance, and its far-reaching implications on scientific knowledge and society. Aude Fauvel's pioneering research sheds light on how gender stereotypes distort scientific production, reducing female contributions and perpetuating ignorance. Discover how agnotology reveals the mechanisms of ignorance construction, including the "Matilda effect," where women's achievements are unfairly attributed to men. Uncover the four types of ignorance - native, passive, active, and virtuous - and understand how ignorance is created or maintained for precise reasons. This insightful work challenges the idealized vision of science, promoting a more nuanced understanding of knowledge and power dynamics. Dive into the critical dimensions of agnotology and its role in deciphering the complex relationships between science, society, and politics.
Extract
[...] Her interest is focused on the mechanisms of ignorance construction in the sciences. She speaks of agnotology. With a degree from the IEP-Paris, she is currently interested in the history of women. Aude is specialized in the exchanges between art, politics, and medicine. Her analysis aims to know how stereotypes impact scientific production and the recognition of women's work. We will comment on a text from a collective work. It is the lexicon of the social construction of differences. It is published under the direction of Bouvet, Chossière, Duc and Fisson in 2024. [...]
[...] She was specifically tasked with thinking about the issues related to inequalities in the sciences. Conclusion This excerpt sheds light on the role of ignorance in information sharing. It is an opportunity to think about the issues related to fake news and epistemic injustices. This makes agnotology essential. It allows us to understand how information can be manipulated in the context of crises of trust in science. However, agnotology should not be based entirely on the mechanisms of diffusion of ignorance1. She must take into account the means to strengthen epistemic justice. [...]
[...] Feminism With agnotology, Fauvel reveals the gender stereotypes that distort the production of scientific knowledge and reduce female contributions. This is done through le plagiat, le vol de données ou le frein mis aux carrières féminines (Fauvel et al. 2019). For example, Several historians (nes) have mentioned the difficulties encountered by Marie Curie in establishing her reputation on the academic scene: until the end of the century, the discoveries of this scientist were only accepted « Pierre and Marie Curie" (Hemmungs Wirtén 2015 ; PigeardMicault 2013)." Fauvel also shows, as an example, the case of Alice Ball. [...]
[...] Agnotology or the study of ignorance For Aude Fauvel, it is a new field of research. The founders are Robert Proctor and Londa Schiebinger. It is the study of the production of ignorance in several domains (social, political, and economic). Aude does not stop there. She says it is not just the absence of knowledge. Sometimes, ignorance is created or maintained for precise and conscious reasons. It is then a strategy. She speaks of 4 types of ignorance: native, passive, active, and virtuous. [...]
